23 Apr 2026New York City FC4β4FC CincinnatiMajor League Soccer
24 Aug 2025FC Cincinnati0β1New York City FCMajor League Soccer
04 May 2025New York City FC1β0FC CincinnatiMajor League Soccer
09 Nov 2024FC Cincinnati0β0New York City FCMajor League Soccer
02 Nov 2024New York City FC3β1FC CincinnatiMajor League Soccer
28 Oct 2024FC Cincinnati1β0New York City FCMajor League Soccer
03 Oct 2024New York City FC3β2FC CincinnatiMajor League Soccer
06 Aug 2024FC Cincinnati4β2New York City FCLeagues Cup
23 Mar 2024FC Cincinnati1β0New York City FCMajor League Soccer
27 Aug 2023FC Cincinnati3β0New York City FCMajor League Soccer
01 Jun 2023New York City FC1β3FC CincinnatiMajor League Soccer
11 May 2023FC Cincinnati1β0New York City FCUS Open Cup
08 Sept 2022New York City FC1β1FC CincinnatiMajor League Soccer
30 Jun 2022FC Cincinnati4β4New York City FCMajor League Soccer
19 Sept 2021FC Cincinnati1β2New York City FCMajor League Soccer
24 Apr 2021New York City FC5β0FC CincinnatiMajor League Soccer
27 Sept 2020New York City FC4β0FC CincinnatiMajor League Soccer
13 Sept 2020New York City FC2β1FC CincinnatiMajor League Soccer
18 Aug 2019FC Cincinnati1β4New York City FCMajor League Soccer
06 Jun 2019New York City FC5β2FC CincinnatiMajor League Soccer