01 Aug 2026New York City FC1–1Toronto FCMajor League Soccer
04 Jul 2025New York City FC3–1Toronto FCMajor League Soccer
26 Apr 2025Toronto FC0–1New York City FCMajor League Soccer
12 May 2024Toronto FC2–3New York City FCMajor League Soccer
16 Mar 2024New York City FC2–1Toronto FCMajor League Soccer
24 Sept 2023New York City FC3–0Toronto FCMajor League Soccer
27 Jul 2023New York City FC5–0Toronto FCLeagues Cup
30 Apr 2023Toronto FC1–0New York City FCMajor League Soccer
24 Apr 2022New York City FC5–4Toronto FCMajor League Soccer
02 Apr 2022Toronto FC2–1New York City FCMajor League Soccer
08 Aug 2021Toronto FC2–2New York City FCMajor League Soccer
15 May 2021New York City FC1–1Toronto FCMajor League Soccer
29 Oct 2020Toronto FC0–1New York City FCMajor League Soccer
24 Sept 2020New York City FC0–1Toronto FCMajor League Soccer
27 Jul 2020Toronto FC1–3New York City FCMajor League Soccer
07 Mar 2020Toronto FC1–0New York City FCMajor League Soccer
24 Oct 2019New York City FC1–2Toronto FCMajor League Soccer
12 Sept 2019New York City FC1–1Toronto FCMajor League Soccer
30 Mar 2019Toronto FC4–0New York City FCMajor League Soccer
12 Aug 2018Toronto FC2–3New York City FCMajor League Soccer
24 Jun 2018New York City FC2–1Toronto FCMajor League Soccer
30 Jul 2017Toronto FC4–0New York City FCMajor League Soccer
20 Jul 2017New York City FC2–2Toronto FCMajor League Soccer
06 Nov 2016New York City FC0–5Toronto FCMajor League Soccer
30 Oct 2016Toronto FC2–0New York City FCMajor League Soccer
19 May 2016Toronto FC1–1New York City FCMajor League Soccer
13 Mar 2016New York City FC2–2Toronto FCMajor League Soccer
17 Sept 2015New York City FC2–0Toronto FCMajor League Soccer
12 Jul 2015New York City FC4–4Toronto FCMajor League Soccer
20 Jun 2015Toronto FC0–2New York City FCMajor League Soccer