14 May 2026New York Red Bulls3–2Columbus CrewMajor League Soccer
18 Oct 2025Columbus Crew3–1New York Red BullsMajor League Soccer
31 Aug 2025New York Red Bulls0–0Columbus CrewMajor League Soccer
03 Nov 2024New York Red Bulls2–2Columbus CrewMajor League Soccer
29 Oct 2024Columbus Crew0–1New York Red BullsMajor League Soccer
20 Oct 2024New York Red Bulls2–3Columbus CrewMajor League Soccer
16 Mar 2024Columbus Crew3–0New York Red BullsMajor League Soccer
02 Jul 2023Columbus Crew2–1New York Red BullsMajor League Soccer
19 Mar 2023New York Red Bulls2–1Columbus CrewMajor League Soccer
02 Oct 2022Columbus Crew2–1New York Red BullsMajor League Soccer
20 Mar 2022New York Red Bulls1–1Columbus CrewMajor League Soccer
23 Oct 2021Columbus Crew1–2New York Red BullsMajor League Soccer
15 Sept 2021Columbus Crew2–1New York Red BullsMajor League Soccer
19 Aug 2021New York Red Bulls1–0Columbus CrewMajor League Soccer
21 Nov 2020Columbus Crew3–2New York Red BullsMajor League Soccer
17 Jul 2020Columbus Crew2–0New York Red BullsMajor League Soccer
28 Jul 2019New York Red Bulls2–3Columbus CrewMajor League Soccer
02 Mar 2019Columbus Crew1–1New York Red BullsMajor League Soccer
12 Nov 2018New York Red Bulls3–0Columbus CrewMajor League Soccer
04 Nov 2018Columbus Crew1–0New York Red BullsMajor League Soccer
29 Jul 2018New York Red Bulls2–3Columbus CrewMajor League Soccer
09 Jun 2018Columbus Crew1–1New York Red BullsMajor League Soccer
24 Sept 2017Columbus Crew3–2New York Red BullsMajor League Soccer
23 Apr 2017New York Red Bulls2–0Columbus CrewMajor League Soccer
16 Oct 2016New York Red Bulls3–2Columbus CrewMajor League Soccer
25 Jun 2016Columbus Crew1–1New York Red BullsMajor League Soccer
30 Nov 2015New York Red Bulls1–0Columbus CrewMajor League Soccer
22 Nov 2015Columbus Crew2–0New York Red BullsMajor League Soccer
04 Oct 2015New York Red Bulls2–1Columbus CrewMajor League Soccer