29 Oct 2026FC Dallas0–2Columbus CrewMajor League Soccer
24 Sept 2023FC Dallas1–1Columbus CrewMajor League Soccer
04 Oct 2020FC Dallas2–2Columbus CrewMajor League Soccer
16 Mar 2019Columbus Crew1–0FC DallasMajor League Soccer
16 Sept 2018FC Dallas0–0Columbus CrewMajor League Soccer
27 Aug 2017Columbus Crew2–1FC DallasMajor League Soccer
03 Apr 2016FC Dallas1–1Columbus CrewMajor League Soccer
07 Sept 2015Columbus Crew0–3FC DallasMajor League Soccer
29 Jun 2014Columbus Crew0–0FC DallasMajor League Soccer
30 Sept 2013FC Dallas2–4Columbus CrewMajor League Soccer
13 May 2012Columbus Crew2–1FC DallasMajor League Soccer