03 Oct 2026Buxton0–2South ShieldsFA Cup
26 Sept 2026South Shields4–0BuxtonNational League - North
02 May 2026South Shields1–0BuxtonNational League - North
03 Jan 2026Buxton1–1South ShieldsNational League - North
30 Aug 2025South Shields2–2BuxtonNational League - North
11 Feb 2025Buxton1–0South ShieldsNational League - North
03 Sept 2024South Shields1–0BuxtonNational League - North
16 Mar 2024Buxton0–2South ShieldsNational League - North
07 Nov 2023South Shields1–0BuxtonNational League - North
05 Feb 2022Buxton2–2South ShieldsNon League Premier - Northern
23 Oct 2021South Shields0–1BuxtonNon League Premier - Northern
22 Feb 2020South Shields1–1BuxtonNon League Premier - Northern
28 Sept 2019Buxton1–2South ShieldsNon League Premier - Northern